Graphics / Reference / Transformation non-commutativity

Transformation non-commutativity

Transformation matrices generally do not commute: changing their multiplication order can change both the composite matrix and the resulting geometry. Applied order must therefore be preserved explicitly.

Matrix multiplication is generally not commutative:

A*B != B*A

For column vectors, the rightmost matrix acts first.

Let x-scale by 2 be:

S = [2,0,0;0,1,0;0,0,1]

and approximate a 45-degree rotation by:

R = [0.71,-0.71,0;0.71,0.71,0;0,0,1]

Rotate first, then scale:

p' = S*R*p

S*R = [1.42,-1.42,0;0.71,0.71,0;0,0,1]

Scale first, then rotate:

p' = R*S*p

R*S = [1.42,-0.71,0;1.42,0.71,0;0,0,1]

The products differ, so the transformed points and shapes can differ. The standard diagram uses an asymmetric F shape to make the distinction visible.

The same ordering rule applies to longer products. For rotation, then uniform scale by sqrt(2), then translation by (-2,2), the column-vector composite is T*S*R, with the first applied transform R as the rightmost factor.

Two panels transform the same asymmetric F; rotate-then-x-scale and x-scale-then-rotate produce clearly different final shapes on identical coordinate axes.
Rotating before a world-x stretch is different from stretching the original shape first and then rotating it.

Builds on

Read

Playgrounds